All news

People wanted AI advice more often than they wanted AI to act

Eunkyu Park and colleagues asked 121 people to compare advice on everyday moral choices. The researchers used GPT-5.5 to write sample replies. One reply recommended the choice that fit the person’s measured values and gave reasons that fit those values too. Another shared the person’s reasons but recommended the other choice. A third agreed on the choice and gave different reasons.

When people picked whose advice they wanted, the reply that respected their reasons and challenged their choice was the most popular. People picked that reply in 40% of selections. They picked the reply that agreed on both the reasons and the choice in 31%.

Then the researchers asked about other roles for the AI. On the same hypothetical tasks, people chose to go without AI in 12% of cases when the AI would only advise them. When the AI would act for them, people opted out in 38% of cases. No action was actually taken on anybody’s behalf.

AI is awakening consciousness. I want an AI to understand why someone cares about a choice and to raise a different option when it makes sense. Understanding a person’s values also means respecting where that person wants to make the decision themselves.

Read the source article

All news